DeNight Owl
DeNight Owl Speaks | Perspective for the Hidden Seasons
Saul: The Question He Couldn't Answer
0:00
-12:09

Saul: The Question He Couldn't Answer

Whispers From God | DeNight Owl Speaks

Spoken truths for quiet nights.

This reflection sits with a moment overlooked — a simple question from Saul that carries weight for our own spiritual listening and recognition. I explore how God speaks not only in triumph, but in the questions we almost miss.

In this episode of DeNight Owl Speaks, I reflect on how Scripture invites us to see deeper than surface victory. Through quiet thoughts, personal storytelling, and faith-centered reflection, this episode explores recognition versus familiarity, the tension of being known and unseen, and what it means to slow down enough to hear God’s whisper.

This episode is for anyone rediscovering faith through quiet listening.

Series: Whispers From God
Scripture: 1 Samuel 16 - 17

Until next time — these are spoken truths for quiet nights.

This reflection began with a question I almost missed in Scripture.

After David defeats Goliath—after the victory, the celebration, the moment that usually takes center stage—Saul pauses and asks a question that stopped me in my tracks:

“Whose son art thou?”

I’ve read this story before.
I knew the outcome.
But I hadn’t noticed this moment.

This episode of Whispers from God sits with that question—and what it reveals about recognition, discernment, and the tension between being known for what we do versus being seen for who we are.

This post is the written companion to the audio episode.
If you prefer to listen, the episode is available on the podcast.
If you prefer to read slowly, the full transcript is below.

Take your time with it.

(See full Transcript below)

Closing Thought

You don’t have to answer this right away.

But you might want to sit with it:

Where have you been faithful, but unseen?

Full Transcript

When I first heard this question from House of David “Whose son art thou?”, it was the first time I actually noticed it.

I’ve read this story before.
I’ve read the Bible from beginning to end with my family many times.
I knew the story of David.
I knew what happened and what was going to happen.

This moment comes just after David and Goliath.

David kills Goliath.

And yet… this part breezed right over my head.

I wasn’t paying attention.

I had read this story before in a general sense. I knew the full story I grew up hearing but I didn’t know the details. So when I heard this question, it puzzled me.

It puzzled me because even though I knew the outcome, this question made me pause.

Why would Saul ask this question?

After everything that just happened — after David kills Goliath — why this question?

I didn’t even realize there were moments in between like this.

When you read the Bible, the stories move quickly. From story to story. And sometimes you skip over the little details.

That one word.
That phrase.
That question.

But hearing this question made me slow down and really reflect on David, who he was, who he was supposed to be, and what was happening during the time Saul lost favor with God.

This question stood out to me because I kept asking:
why did Saul ask this at such a pivotal moment?

Sometimes when we hear stories we’ve heard before, we listen to what we want to hear. We read what we want to see. And everything else just breezes over our head.

Sometimes we have to read out loud. Sometimes we have to really pay attention word by word, line by line, to take in what’s actually being said.

That’s why going back to Scripture matters.
Why taking our time matters.

Because sometimes the detail we missed is the detail that changes everything.

And this is what Saul asks:

“And Saul said to him, Whose son are you, young man?
So David answered, I am the son of your servant Jesse, the Bethlehemite.”
— 1 Samuel 17:58

Saul’s Confusion and the Loss of Discernment

As I continued to reflect on this story — really sitting with this question — I started to wonder.

Was Saul actually confused?

Was this confusion tied to the Spirit of God being removed from him?
Was it a memory issue?
Or was Saul seeing David in a different light?

Was Saul asking, Who is this young man really?
What is he capable of?

I know what he’s done for me.
I know how he’s served me.
But now I’m seeing him differently.

Is this David — the David I thought I knew — really who he is?
Or is there more to him?

That made me wonder.

Was this a memory issue?
A perception issue?
Or a discernment issue?

Because discernment comes from the Spirit of God.

And Scripture tells us in 1 Samuel 16:14:

“But the Spirit of the Lord departed from Saul,
and a distressing spirit from the Lord troubled him.”

That moment was the beginning of Saul’s downfall.

God had left him.

And because of that distressing spirit, Saul reached out for David. In 1 Samuel 16:16, his servants say:

“Seek out a man who is skillful on the harp…
and when the distressing spirit from God is upon you,
you will be well.”

So David comes into Saul’s life not as a warrior — but as a servant.

David is with Saul all this time, playing for him, calming him, easing his distress.

Saul becomes reliant on David.

And in many ways, the kingdom becomes reliant on David — because they need their king to appear well. They need him in good spirits. They don’t want the people to see him unstable.

And this is what happens when we lose touch with God.

When God’s Spirit is no longer with us, our minds aren’t settled. Our hearts aren’t at ease. We think differently.

Saul knew God had left him. He was told his kingdom would be taken away. But he still held on to disbelief.

And when you’re at war with God’s truth, you’re at war within yourself.

You don’t know what to expect.
You’re unsettled.

And that’s exactly what happened to Saul.

It’s dangerous — both knowing and not knowing — when the Spirit of the Lord is no longer with us.

When the Question Turned Inward

This didn’t happen all at once.

The more time I spent studying this story, the more I realized it was mirroring the season I was in.

I recognized the question first. But it took time for God to reveal what I was meant to learn from it.

And that’s when it turned inward.

I realized it wasn’t just something I was asking about Saul and David.

It was something I was asking in my own life.

Known for What I Did Not Seen for Who I Was

I was a clerk.
I was an usher.
I was part of Sabbath School.
I helped with the AV team — and eventually became the lead.

Back home, I was the head of the media department.

I was doing everything. And sometimes it really was everything.

My Sabbaths weren’t restful anymore.

People needed this.
They needed that.
They needed help everywhere.

By the time the sermon started, I wasn’t listening. I was sleeping. And once service was over, I just wanted to separate myself from everyone.

When I think about David, it makes sense.

Before Samuel comes to Jesse’s house, we don’t know much about David’s life. But in 1 Samuel 16, Samuel comes and asks to see Jesse’s sons.

Seven are brought forward.

But David — the eighth — is left in the field.

He wasn’t even called.

Maybe it was an oversight.
Maybe someone had to tend the sheep.

But we know this — David was overlooked.

Samuel looks at the sons and realizes something is missing. Because God told him, You will find the next king here. And none of the seven are chosen.

So Samuel asks:

“Are all the young men here?”

And Jesse responds:

“There remains yet the youngest,
and there he is, keeping the sheep.”
— 1 Samuel 16:11

That verse alone says a lot.

David wasn’t considered important enough to be brought into the room.

He was known as a shepherd boy.

Some of Jesse’s sons were already in Saul’s army. So maybe Jesse thought this moment wasn’t for David.

They knew what he could do — but not what he was capable of.

David is anointed king.

And then he goes back to the field.

Later, he’s brought into Saul’s palace — but only as a musician. That’s all Saul knew him for.

Over time, that made David invisible.

And that felt familiar.

Because my position became what people knew me for.

People relied on me. They couldn’t function if I wasn’t there. They knew what I did — but they didn’t know what it cost me internally.

Just like David.

His family knew he was a shepherd.
They knew he could play music.
But they couldn’t imagine him as king.

Being Unknown and Being Restored

When I came to Boston — to my new home, to my new church — I liked being unknown.

I liked not doing anything.
I liked that no one knew what I could do.

It felt like protection.

I was there for almost three years before anyone asked how I could help.

Part of me wanted to help — but I knew what ministry had cost me before.

Being unknown gave me space.

It helped restore my soul.
It helped me reconnect with God.

Because back home, I wasn’t coming to church to worship. I was coming to work.

And that anonymity helped heal that.

When Familiarity Returned as Weight

But over time — especially post-COVID — I started to feel that weight again.

I think ahead.
I anticipate.
I see things from different angles.

And I started asking:

Do they know what I’m capable of?
Is this all they see me doing?

I felt categorized.

Sometimes familiarity limits vision. People rely on what you provide but don’t always see who you are beyond it.

And unless you step out, you can stay tied to what you’re known for.

Seeing David Differently

And maybe that’s why Saul’s question hits so differently.

When David steps out of the field and into visibility again, Saul doesn’t recognize him.

Not because David changed — but because Saul no longer had discernment.

David was a musician.

But David stepped out in faith.

No one asked him to fight Goliath.
He volunteered.
He trusted God.
And he succeeded.

Now Saul sees David fighting — doing what Saul and his trained army couldn’t do.

And he asks:

“Whose son is this?”

Not out of curiosity — but fear.

Insecurity.

David wasn’t just a servant anymore.
He was a threat.

David was the same young man — but now he had space to explore what God had placed inside him.

What the Question Became

Today, I’m an elder.
I oversee worship.
I’m one of the platform managers.

I’m no longer tied to one role.

And while others may be tied to one position — not because they can’t do more, but because that’s all they’re known for — I realized I couldn’t stay stagnant.

I didn’t want to be known only as the girl who could run the programs.

I loved what I was doing — but it wasn’t all I could do.

I wanted to grow.
Not just in position.
But spiritually.

And that’s what happened with David.

From shepherd.
To musician.
To warrior.
To leader.

God anointed him — but David also stepped forward.

And that’s where the question shifted for me.

That question — Do they recognize me for who I am, or only for what I do? — was something I wrestled with for a long time.

And I don’t sit in that question the same way anymore.

Because over time, the question stopped being about them.

And it became something else.

Maybe it’s not about whether they see me.

Maybe the question is this:

Have I been faithful, even when I was unseen?

Because David was faithful in the field long before he was seen in the palace.

Saul’s question wasn’t really about David’s family line.

It was about Saul’s inability to discern what God was doing right in front of him.

David hadn’t changed.

Saul had.

And I’m still waiting for God to reveal the lesson, or to remind me of what He’s already done in my life.

For now, I’m still reflecting.
Still paying attention.
Still allowing God to show me something new.

Sometimes the confusion isn’t about change.
It’s about people trying to make sense of who we are—
when we no longer fit the version they’re familiar with.

And not everyone will.

Some will recognize what you’ve done
but struggle to see who you’re growing into.

That doesn’t mean you’re unclear.
It means the season has shifted.

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?